Crazy, You Call This a Trainee Lawyer Chapter 307

   Chapter 307 Grabbing bags but not money? Excuse!

   in court.

   "On that day, I was walking down the street, and suddenly a man rushed in front of me, reaching out and grabbing my wallet!"

   "Excuse the witness, is that man in court?"

   "Yes!"

  Ms. Zong raised her hand and pointed at Yan Dayuan on the defense table, "Here, it's him!"

   "Are you sure?"

   "Of course, I can recognize his appearance even if it's turned to ashes!"

   Hearing this, many people on the jury showed a clear look.

  OK!

  The murderer has been confirmed, but it is not the one in the dock.

   The case can be closed!

   In just a few sentences, the case was settled.

  Closed the case at the speed of light!

   On the defense table, Zhang Wei naturally saw the mind of the jury.

   Good guy, the first question is to close the case, right?

   Do you dare to go faster?

   But he complained, and the prosecution statement must continue.

   "Then ask Ms. Zong, what did this man do after that?"

   "He stole my wallet, I definitely wouldn't let it, so I fought with her, but I'm a weak woman, and I'm old, how could I be his opponent, so he stole my wallet."

   Ms. Zong said, showing the back of her hand, "Here, these are the scratches that were caught while fighting with him. This man is really bad!"

   The jury understood, and many nodded their heads in agreement.

   "And after that?" Chai Ping continued to ask.

   "After he stole the wallet, he opened it directly in front of me and wanted to find money. Of course, I stared at him fiercely, and remember what he looked like."

   "However, after a while, he suddenly held my wallet and started rushing towards me, shouting something while rushing back. I was very scared and ran away."

   "After that, I ran and shouted 'kill you', hoping to get other people's attention, and then I heard movement behind me, and I stopped."

   Ms. Zong said, patted her chest, and said with a look of happiness: "There are a few young men around, and they helped me knock down the man when they heard me calling for help!"

"I see!"

  Chai Ping nodded immediately and said, "If there were no helpers who are enthusiastic citizens, what kind of treatment do you think you would receive, Ms. Zong?"

   "I think so..."

   "Cough!"

   Just as Chai Ping was leading the witness to make a guess, Zhang Wei suddenly coughed.

   Lin Yumeng finally reacted, this is the master's signal.

   "Objection, the prosecution is leading the witnesses to speculate!"

   "Well, the objection is valid!" The judge also nodded.

   This sudden interruption made Chai Ping stunned.

   Good guy, you Zhang Wei also said that you would not participate in the trial. Is this what you call non-participation?

   Zhang Wei sneered in response to Chai Ping's gaze.

What's wrong?

   I have a bad throat, what's wrong with a cough?

  You want to catch my feet?

  Dream you!

   In this small confrontation, naturally the defense has the advantage.

   But Chai Ping wasn't annoyed, he just didn't like Zhang Wei.

   He asked again: "Ms. Zong, when the defendant was subdued, what did he think of you?

   "He, of course, is looking at me with a fierce look, I feel like he wants to kill!"

   "Objection, lead witnesses to speculate!"

   Chai Ping's question was once again opposed by Lin Yumeng.

   "Prosecutor?"

   This time, the judge also has an opinion.

   How did you make two mistakes in a row?

  Chai Ping immediately showed an apologetic expression, which was considered a mistake.

   He then looked at the defense table, looked at Yan Dayuan, and asked with a sneer, "Ms. Zong, can you please describe the most critical wallet in this case?"

"Of course, this wallet is a gift from my daughter. At that time, she bought a fan with a cartoon pattern. Anyway, my daughter is filial, so I will use it." Ms. Zong said without hesitation. .

   After hearing this, Chai Ping immediately concluded: "Ms. Zong's wallet is a pink wallet with a cartoon hellokitty pattern. It was a gift from her daughter. Why would the defendant target such a wallet?"

   "I remember that after the defendant was arrested, he explained it this way. He said that the wallet was very similar to his, so he suspected that Ms. Zong had stolen his wallet."

   "Then I feel strange, what kind of man would actually use such a wallet?"

   After he finished speaking, he looked towards the jury.

  Many people were happy, both men and women, all looked at the defendant Yan Dayuan with disbelief.

   A big man actually uses hellokitty's pink wallet, isn't it a bit too…

   Just as Chai Ping was leading the jury, Zhang Wei poked his apprentice on the arm.

   "Objection!" The latter even got a conditioned reflex and stood up.

   "Reason for objection?" The judge was also stunned.

   "Master, what is the reason for objection?" Lin Yumeng hurriedly called for help.

   Zhang Wei hurriedly opened his mouth and made a mouth shape.

   "Oh, the objection is a personal attack!"

  Lin Yumeng said, and hurriedly added: "There is no rule, a big gentleman can't use a pink wallet with hellokitty, right?"

"Uh…"

   Although the judge also felt that this kind of thing was a bit perverted, he couldn't help but hammered and announced: "The objection is valid!"

   "The jury, the last sentence of the prosecution's statement just now is of a personal attack nature, please ignore it!"

   In the jury, two people nodded pretentiously, but more people did not respond.

  Obviously, the judge's words did not have much binding effect.

   Seeing his "great achievements", Chai Ping was satisfied now.

   "Your Excellency, the prosecution has nothing to ask about this witness!"

   He walked back to the prosecution table with a smile and ended his statement at the same time.

   The next moment, the audience's eyes were focused on the defense seat, or on Lin Yumeng's body.

   The latter's little hands trembled a little, but he still resisted the uneasiness in his heart and walked to the court.

   "Hello, Ms. Zong."

   "Hello, little girl."

   Ms. Zong on the witness stand did not show much hostility after seeing Lin Yumeng appear in court.

   "That...I want to ask, my client, Mr. Yan Dayuan, he stole your wallet, right?"

"Yeah, he robbed it. I know what you're asking. I'm not blind, and my eyesight is very good. It's impossible to recognize the wrong person. Besides, there are several guys on the spot besides me. They It's impossible to admit the wrong person, if you don't believe it, you can call them to court, and we can face it together!"

  Ms. Zong answered some questions in advance like a prophet.

   Needless to say, these questions must have been conceived by Chai Ping for her, which is also a common routine for defense lawyers.

  Once a witness has made an accusation, the defense lawyer will definitely raise objections on the grounds of "whether the witness saw it wrongly" or "whether the witness did not see it clearly".

  If the witness is old, there are more reasons to use it.

   So in order to deal with the defense's routine, Chai Ping naturally also prepared countermeasures.

   "That...I didn't mean to ask these..."

   But Lin Yumeng shook his head and denied this.

   "I just wanted to ask, when my client Mr. Yan stole your wallet, did he take the money in it?"

   "This..." Ms. Zong was at a loss for words.

   "Huh?" Lin Yumeng blinked and looked at the former.

   "Witness, please think carefully, and then answer the question!" The judge also immediately interjected and gave a warning.

   "That, I remember he looked over the money at the time..."

   "Did he take the money?"

   "It seems...not really..."

When    Ms. Zong replied, her face became a little unnatural.

  Because the man sitting in the dock stole his wallet, but he didn't seem to take any money out of it.

   "Oh, then can I think that my client really didn't want to rob your wallet, but just thought that your wallet was very similar to his, so he wanted to take a look?"

"this…"

"be opposed to!"

Before Ms. Zong could answer, Chai Ping had already raised an objection.

  The judge saw this and was also ready to speak.

   "Your Majesty, my question is over!"

   But Lin Yumeng ended the question first and went straight back to the defense seat.

   This scene also made many people wonder.

   You just asked such a simple question and it's over?

Is    a little too short?

   "Master, just ask a question, isn't it too short?"

   Fortunately, Lin Yumeng raised questions for everyone.

   "It's not short, it's not short, on the contrary, it's just right. You don't need to ask too much. The jury only needs to remember one thing, that is, Yan Dayuan didn't want to steal money!"

   Zhang Wei pointed to the jury bench and explained.

   When I saw the jury, many people looked suspicious.

   Grab the wallet but not the money, why is this?

   Is the defendant's explanation true, a big man really used a wallet with a pink cartoon pattern?

   Zhang Wei nodded when he saw this effect.

   He was very satisfied with the result of this question, even if it was just one question, it was enough.

   Stealing wallet = robbing money, this is what many people think subconsciously, so in the eyes of many people, it is a serious crime of robbery.

   But if only one bag is stolen without the money inside, then in the eyes of the jury, the nature is completely different.

   They will doubt the authenticity of the defendant's testimony, and this trace of doubt is Zhang Wei's purpose.

   "Damn!"

   Chai Ping also noticed the change in the jury's wind direction, and immediately showed an angry look.

   And all the newcomers in the hearing booth were all showing adoring expressions at this moment, and began to take notes frantically.

  Because they also saw the change in the court's wind direction, all of which were developing in the favor of the defense.

   "The prosecution?"

   On the bench, the judge spoke again.

   The anger on Chai Ping's face quickly subsided, and finally he showed a sneer at Zhang Wei on the defense table.

  I still have a back up. Even if the first witness was swept away by you, let's see how you deal with the second one.

   "Your Excellency Judge, the prosecution requests to summon Cai Cadre, who was in charge of the case at the time, to testify in court!"

   "This court approves!"

   As he was summoned, a woman in her thirties took to the court.

   She was wearing the uniform of the investigation department, her face was serious, and she was quite serious.

   "Hello Officer Cai!" Chai Ping also walked to the witness stand and greeted him with a serious face.

   "Hello, prosecutor!"

   After hearing Cadman Cai's response, he immediately asked: "Excuse me, Officer Cai, what did you hear him say when you were arresting the defendant?"

   "He said he didn't plan to rob, and then made up a very outrageous reason."

   "Did he say that the victim's wallet resembles his?"

   "Yes, but I think this reasoning is too perfunctory!"

"Perfunctory?"

  Chai pretended to be surprised, and immediately asked, "Excuse me, why is this reason so perfunctory?"

   Officer Cai looked at the defense table, and then showed a disdainful smile: "I've heard this excuse a lot, it's just that the suspect sees that there is too little money in his wallet, so he wants to use this excuse to prevaricate it!"

"In a situation like this, if you encounter some timid victims, if you see that there is a lot of things in your wallet, maybe you will not pursue the defendant for fear of trouble, then he can continue to commit crimes until he is reported to the police for arrest, or robbed. It will be closed until a wallet with a lot of money!"

   "Oh, so that's how it is!"

  Chai Ping finally showed a "sudden realization" when he heard this explanation.

   And in the same way, the jury had the same expression when they heard these words.

   Good guy, it looks like this defendant is a repeat offender, so he came up with such an idea.

   He must have seen that there was no money in Ms. Zong's wallet, so he thought of using this excuse to get rid of the accusation, but he didn't expect to be thrown down by three or four big men before returning the wallet.

   "Carrier Cai, can I ask again, is this the first time the defendant has committed a crime?"

   "Of course not, he's a repeat offender!"

Officer Cai said, recalling: "According to our criminal record investigation, the defendant's first crime was at the age of 16, and it was the crime of theft. After that, his criminal record began to increase, not only for theft and robbery, but also for assault and assault. Others, gathering to gamble, illegal parking, etc..."

  The wind in the courtroom changed again as cadre Cai uttered a long list of records.

   This time, the jury looked at the dock with strong contempt.

  You are still a habitual offender, and you have a lot of crimes!

  Although many of them are not serious crimes, you must be good at petty theft, you are wrong!

  Then the witness's explanation just now makes sense. You are a repeat offender, and you must be thinking of using that reason to prevaricate.

   Guilty!

  You are definitely guilty!

   It can be said that the jury at this moment almost expresses their inner thoughts through expressions.

   If the voting starts now, it must be guilty, and it is also guilty by unanimous vote.

  Chai Ping saw the jury's reaction, and this time the corner of his mouth smirked again.

   This is steady!

   "Thanks to cadre Cai for the answer, the prosecution has no more questions to ask!"

   He thought he had achieved the lore.

   not only dismissed the defense's rebuttal just now, but also allowed the jury to learn about the defendant's numerous crimes.

   Moreover, Cadman Cai is a more serious witness, he believes that it is absolutely impossible for the defense to take her down.

   Therefore, Chaiping was very relieved and ended the question directly.

   "Defense, it's your turn!"

   The judge spoke quickly and reminded the defense to come up for cross-examination.

   The little apprentice wanted to go to court, but when he saw the cold gaze of Officer Cai, he immediately lowered his head and hesitated.

   "Master, what should I do, I'm a little scared..."

   "What are you afraid of, you can ask whatever you need to ask. Did I train you for so long in vain?"

   Zhang Wei encouraged Lin Yumeng again, and then pushed her out.

   The little apprentice took small steps and walked to the witness stand step by step.

   "Hello, witness..."

   "Hello, lawyer!"

  For Lin Yumeng, Cai cadre has no good attitude.

   Her answer was succinct, or without a trace of emotion, as cold as a machine.

   "Excuse me, witness, did you not believe what he said when you caught my client..."

   "Of course, my job is to contact bad guys, and when a bad guy is arrested, no one will ever plead guilty, unless he has a problem with his brain!"

   "But my client, my brain is fine..."

   "So he made an excuse, but I broke it down!"

   Officer Cai sneered, you defense lawyer, your questions are really not good.

   At the same time, Chai Ping on the prosecution table also laughed.

  This looks like a nine out of ten, oh no, it's a ten out of ten!

  Lin Yumeng's question was easily answered by Cai cadre.

   What other tricks do you have, come out quickly!

   "Well, I want to ask, you just said a lot of my client's criminal record, right?"

"yes!"

   "Then may I ask, when was the last time my client committed a crime?"

"Last time?"

   Officer Cai showed a hint of doubt, but quickly searched for data in his mind.

   "Yan Dayuan's last crime was five years ago. The crime was a street fight, and then he spent two years in prison. He behaved well in prison..."

   "Then may I ask, what is the average interval between my client's previous crimes?"

   "Every year, the average cycle has not been counted."

   "Witness, that is to say, before the last crime, my client was arrested for the crime every year, but after the last time, is it possible that he has reformed?"

"this…"

   Officer Cai's expression finally changed.

   Because of this kind of thing, she can't judge.

   "My client has not done bad things for 5 years. He has been honest for 5 years. How can he suddenly **** someone else's wallet?"

   "I really can't answer this question, because I'm not the defendant and I don't know what he thinks!"

  Lin Yumeng nodded, but still asked, "Is that possible?"

   "Objection, guide the witness to speculate!"

  Chai Ping saw Cadman Cai's hesitation and got up quickly.

   He didn't expect that this serious cadre Cai would be affected by a little girl's question.

   "Your Majesty, I have a reason to ask this question, because the witness is an experienced operator, he must have contacted many suspects, so she must have contacted people who have similar experiences with my client!"

   "This... seems to make some sense..."

The judge    also hesitated.

   On the one hand, Chai Ping made sense, but Lin Yumeng also made sense.

   In the end, he decided to leave the question to the witness himself.

   "Carrier Cai, can you answer this question?"

   "I think so!"

   "Well then, you can answer!"

The judge agreed, and Chai Ping had no choice but to sit down.

After thinking about it for a while, Officer Cai replied, "I can't rule out the possibility, although many people won't be honest all the time, but someone like the defendant who has been honest for five years does have the possibility of reforming himself! "

   "Thank you witness, I have no more questions to ask!"

  Lin Yumeng immediately expressed her gratitude upon hearing this answer, and finally bowed 90° to the witness stand.

   And with this question, the winds of the court have changed again.

   But this time, the wind blew slightly towards the defense.

   Just finished nucleic acid

   (end of this chapter)

Chapter end